Zinnia Arora - Rank 6 - 2025
You are an IAS officer, currently serving as the
Secretary of the Public Works Department in a hill state. Recently, a
disturbing incident has come to light involving a senior Cabinet Minister and
two engineers of the National Highways Authority of India (NHAI). During an
inspection of a critical highway project, the Minister was allegedly seen on
video physically assaulting and verbally abusing the engineers in full public
view. The video, recorded by bystanders, went viral on social media and was
widely covered by television channels, sparking both outrage and support from
different sections of society.
The Minister later defended his actions, alleging
that the officials were corrupt, unresponsive to local grievances, and
responsible for inordinate delays in the project. He insisted that his actions
were driven by public frustration and the urgency of delivering infrastructure
to a remote region.
However, the engineers have filed a police complaint
and written to their superiors, claiming they were targeted for resisting
political pressure to award contracts to specific local contractors linked to
the Minister. As the situation escalated, a union of NHAI engineers declared a
strike, demanding action against the Minister and protection of officer
dignity. This has brought several critical infrastructure projects to a
standstill, including road connectivity to tribal areas, pre-monsoon repair
works, and strategic border roads.
You have been directed by the Chief Secretary to
prepare a fact-finding report, while also ensuring smooth coordination between
state and central agencies. Meanwhile, the Minister's office is informally
pressuring you to downplay the incident. The media is sharply divided — some
portraying the Minister as a crusader against corruption, others condemning the
act as a serious breach of administrative ethics and rule of law. Civil
servants across departments have expressed concern about personal safety,
dignity, and increasing political interference, while citizens are now growing
restless due to halted infrastructure works.
(a)
What are the key
ethical issues involved in this situation? Identify the stakeholders and their
conflicting interests.
(b)
As the Secretary of
the PWD, what actions will you take in the above situation?
(c)
How do such
incidents affect the morale of civil servants and public trust in governance?
The given case study reflects
stakeholder conflict and a potential case of corruption, in addition to
political interference and violence against personnel.
Vision: "Think strategically, act democratically."
(a)
Ethical issues and stakeholders
1.
Minister
- Political sanguinity.
- Pressure tactics
- Administrative ethics violation.
- Use of delinquent means of violence (Himsa).
- Potential corruption → Lack of probity.
2. Engineers
- Officer dignity.
- Courage to counter political pressure.
- Reactive measures.
- Potential problems of non-partisan work.
3. Union
- Protection of worker rights.
- Collective protection and bargaining.
- Disregard for public good.
4.
Citizens
- Lack of infrastructure access.
- Trust-based governance: lack of trust.
- Confused loyalties.
5. Media
- Partisan reporting.
- Verifiable fact-finding yet to be done.
- Upright reporting amiss
- Lack of willingness to help maintain public discipline.
- Profiteering urge.
(b) Actions
1. Set up
a fact-finding committee.
Rationale:
- Verifiability.
- Objectivity.
- Process-based working.
- Hierarchy flow (Webber/Weber).
2.
Dialogue with both parties to understand their side of the story.
- Tolerance of opinions and accusations.
- Honest understanding.
3.
Maintain a record of ministerial pressure.
- Ask for written directives
- (T.S.R. Subramanian case)
Rationale:
- Accountability balanced with rationality.
- Rational disobedience against ill-informed orders.
- Non-partisan working.
4. Media:
Statement release.
- Request media to be ethical in reporting.
- Solicit time from people => Assurance-based
governance.
- Inform the public about the progress. “Informed
citizenry is the currency of democracy.” – Jt. Shah
5. Sit
with the union.
- Discuss the need to balance citizens' rights with own.
- Officer duty => lost in ‘service
of the poor’ Vivekananda
(c)
Impact on service morale and public trust
A.
Civil servants' morale
1. Falling synergy between political executive and permanent executive.
- Political executive and permanent civil service must
work together for service delivery. (Venn Diagram)
2. Lack of will to stay truthful.
3. Chilling effect – Public harassment.
4. Whistleblower rights violation
- Deterrence against probity.
- Example: Manjunath – IOCL case.
5. Failing specter of role models.
6. Antagonism over 'temperance' (virtue ethics).
7. Teleological ends pursued.
- Lack of care for hill-state citizens.
B.
Public trust
- Falling trust.
- Responsibility dilution.
- Lack of relatability.
- Reactive Approch*
- Fatalism towards public servants.*
Thus, it is crucial to instil
officer protection (Articles 309, 312), whilst ensuring political actors use
dialogue over deterrence.
---------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------
Key Words Explanation
Chilling effect
· A situation in which the fear of punishment, harassment or retaliation discourages individuals from performing their duties or expressing legitimate concerns
· For example, engineers who witness political interference may stop reporting irregularities because they fear personal consequences.
Stakeholder conflict
A situation in which different individuals or groups have different expectations, interests and priorities.
In this case:
· The Minister wants quick project execution and political control.
· Engineers want professional dignity and freedom from political pressure.
· The union wants protection of employees.
· Citizens want uninterrupted infrastructure development.
The administrator must balance these competing interests without compromising public interest.
Political sanguinity
Sanguinity means optimism or confidence about an outcome.
* In this context, it may indicate excessive political confidence or an attitude of political dominance. It is not a standard term for political interference. A more precise expression would be political arrogance or political overreach.
Pressure tactics
Using authority, influence, threats or intimidation to compel someone to act according to one's wishes
Officer dignity
· The respect, professional independence and personal dignity that government officials deserve while performing their duties
· It does not mean that officers are above criticism. They must remain accountable for their actions while being protected from humiliation, threats and physical violence.
Confused loyalties
A situation in which an individual faces competing loyalties and finds it difficult to decide which one deserves priority.
Verifiable fact-finding
An investigation based on facts that can be independently checked and supported by reliable evidence.
It involves:
· Examining video footage.
· Recording witness statements.
· Examining official documents.
· Verifying allegations of corruption.
· Establishing the sequence of events.
The objective is to distinguish facts from allegations and opinions.
Delinquent means of violence (Himsa)
· Delinquent means unlawful or improper conduct. Himsa means violence or causing harm.
Probity
· Probity means absolute honesty, integrity and uprightness in public life.
· It goes beyond merely avoiding corruption. It also involves transparency, impartiality, accountability and ethical conduct.
Reactive measures
· Actions taken only after a problem has occurred rather than anticipating and preventing it.
· For example, taking action against political intimidation only after an incident becomes viral.
Hierarchy flow – Max Weber
· Max Weber's bureaucratic model emphasises a well-defined hierarchy, division of responsibilities, formal rules and systematic procedures.
· In this case, administrative decisions should move through the proper chain of command, with clear responsibility and accountability.
· The idea is that governance should function through institutions rather than the personal wishes of powerful individuals.
T.S.R. Subramanian case
The reference is to T.S.R. Subramanian v. Union of India (2013).
The Supreme Court emphasised institutional reforms in civil services, including:
· Written instructions for civil servants.
· Civil Services Boards.
· Fixed tenure for civil servants, subject to prescribed conditions.
· Protection of civil servants from arbitrary political interference.
The case is relevant to maintaining administrative neutrality and professional independence.
Rational disobedience
· The conscious refusal to follow an unlawful, unethical or unconstitutional instruction.
· It does not mean disobeying every inconvenient order.
Manjunath – IOCL case
· This refers to the case of S. Manjunath, an Indian Oil Corporation officer who was murdered in 2005 after exposing fuel adulteration.
· He is remembered as an example of integrity and professional courage.
· His case illustrates the risks faced by public officials who challenge corruption and the need for institutional protection for honest officers.
Teleological ends pursued
· Teleology is the philosophical study of purpose or ends.
· A teleological approach evaluates actions in terms of their consequences or intended outcomes.
· However, a desirable outcome cannot automatically justify unethical or unlawful means. This is an important ethical distinction: Ends do not always justify the means.
Lack of relatability
· A disconnect between public institutions and citizens' actual experiences, concerns and expectations.
· When people repeatedly face delayed infrastructure projects and insensitive administration, they may feel that government institutions are disconnected from their lives.
Officer protection – Articles 309 and 312
· Article 309: Provides for the regulation of recruitment and conditions of service of persons serving the Union or a State.
· Article 312: Provides for the creation of All India Services common to the Union and the States, subject to constitutional conditions.
These provisions concern civil service structures and service conditions. They should not be interpreted as direct guarantees against physical assault or political harassment. Protection against such conduct must also be pursued through applicable laws, service rules and institutional safeguards.







